What could go wrong

When family plans go wrong: 12 stories

The Swiss cheese of family estates: each hole alone is small. When they line up, a family ends up in court.

Which of these is your family?

Helping isn’t the problem. Helping without a written plan is.

Illustration: Thanksgiving in Long Beach: five grown children, one table, Carol’s mother’s china.STORY 1

The trust the survivor could rewrite

Carol and Ray had five children between them and one trust. After Carol died, the trust let Ray rewrite it, and everything went to his two sons.

Illustration: Saturday morning: a grandson drives his grandpa to the hardware store.STORY 2

The signature in the hard season

A memory diagnosis, a son who drove Dad everywhere, a signature no one else saw. The other two found out after he died.

Illustration: 2004: Bob puts the trust binder on the hall-closet shelf. No probate, girls.STORY 3

The house that slipped out of the trust

Bob and Marlene promised their daughters “no probate.” One refinance quietly took the house out of the trust.

Illustration: Sunday lunch in the courtyard Grandma built her life around.STORY 4

The grandson who ran the six-plex

Grandma’s grandson ran her building, picked up her prescriptions and took over her mail. Then he typed her new will.

Illustration: Easter on the Glendale porch: three grown kids, one even split, like always.STORY 5

Three weeks before he died

Dad’s 2012 will said “even, like always.” Three weeks before he died, a will typed in his hospital room left the house to Luis.

Illustration: 2009: Martin and Yolanda’s backyard wedding. Five grown children, one dance floor.STORY 6

The house that went to the second wife

One signature at a 2011 refinance decided who got Dad’s house. It wasn’t his children.

Illustration: Altadena: Denise does her parents’ taxes; everyone stays for dinner.STORY 7

The sister who went quiet

Denise did her parents’ taxes for years. As trustee she went quiet, and her brothers stopped trusting her.

Illustration: The Downey house where all four grew up, and where everyone still gathers.STORY 8

Sold to the brother, cheap

Steve was trustee and wanted the family house. He bought it at his friend’s number; his sisters saw a listing two streets over for much more.

Illustration: A single dad and his two kids at the beach in El Segundo.STORY 9

The form from 1994

Dad’s trust split everything between his two kids. A form he signed in 1994 sent his biggest account to his ex-wife.

Illustration: Halloween in Pico Rivera: every costume on the block came off Teresa’s machine.STORY 10

The note on the kitchen table

Mama’s note under the sugar bowl: her handwriting, no date. Three children read it three different ways.

Illustration: Thirty years at the Gardena nursery, with daughters and grandkids in the rows.STORY 11

The original that disappeared

Everyone knew Kenji had a will. After two moves, only a copy turned up, and his late son’s children lost part of what he meant for them.

Illustration: Eleanor’s birthday in Pomona: three children around one table.STORY 12

Paid for his time

Gary paid Mom’s bills, banks and doctors for four years, and paid himself by the hour. His sisters called it something else.

Illustration. Not a real family.

The Swiss cheese of family estates

Pilots have a picture for how airplanes go down. It is a stack of Swiss cheese slices. Every slice has holes. Most days the holes never line up, and the flight lands. On a bad day they do.

Safety people call it the Swiss cheese model. Each slice is one layer of protection: the training, the checklist, the weather briefing, the second engine, the controller on the radio. None of them is perfect. A night flight is manageable. So is bad weather. So is a rough-running engine. Put all three in the same hour, with a tired crew and a radio that cuts out, and the holes start to line up.

Families are built the same way. Almost every family has a few holes. One child moved to Oregon. There was a second marriage. One daughter does all the driving to appointments and the others send money. Somebody has always felt like the favorite, or like the one who was not. The house is in joint names with one child “to keep it simple.” The will is in the dresser drawer, signed in 1998.

Any one of those is ordinary. Lined up together, at the worst possible moment, they are how a family that loved each other ends up in a courtroom, with lawyers on both sides and the house sitting empty while it is sorted out.

Why a library of things that went wrong

John J. Donahue has practiced law in California since 1990, and a large part of that work has been in probate court, after the fact, when a will or a trust is being fought over. His sister site, myinheritance.com, is written for families already in that fight.

This library runs the same stories backward. Each one starts with what happened, then shows which holes lined up, then asks the question nobody had time to ask before: what would have headed it off? The answers are rarely exotic. Most of the time it was wording that should have predicted the trouble, wishes that were never said out loud, or a family that never heard the plan from the person who made it.

Every story here is an illustration, built from patterns that come up again and again. None of them is a real family, and none of them is legal advice for yours.

The holes, and the stories behind them

Start with whichever hole looks most like your family. Each link opens the story where that hole did the damage.

What closes the holes

No plan closes every hole. The point is to close enough of them that they cannot line up. In John’s experience on the courtroom side, the same few habits do most of the work:

  • Wording that expects the trouble. If a second marriage, a distant child or a helper child is part of the picture, the documents should say how that is handled, in plain words, instead of hoping it never comes up.
  • Wishes said out loud. A short letter, in the parent’s own words, explaining why the plan looks the way it does. It is not a legal document. It is often the thing that keeps one.
  • The family hears it from the source. A family meeting while the parent is well, so nobody learns the plan from a sibling after the funeral. Children who live out of state can join on a recorded video call.
  • Papers that match the plan. Deeds, accounts and beneficiary forms checked against the trust, and checked again after any refinance, sale or move.
  • A review when life changes. A marriage, a death, a diagnosis or a move to another state is the moment to look again, not the moment to put it off.

Where to begin

If you are planning for yourself or a parent, the living trusts, blended family planning, power of attorney and health care directive pages are a good place to start. The planning steps page walks through how a plan comes together.

If one of these holes looks familiar, it is far easier to close it now, while everyone can still sit at the same table. Call John at (310) 735-9877, or send a note from the contact page.