What could go wrong · A trustee no one can see into

The sister who went quiet

Illustration: Altadena: Denise does her parents’ taxes; everyone stays for dinner.
1 · THE FAMILY WHOLEAltadena: Denise does her parents’ taxes; everyone stays for dinner.Illustration. Not a real family.

What happened

When Harold and June made their trust in 2015, choosing the trustee took about a minute. Their daughter Denise was a bookkeeper in Pasadena, lived twenty minutes away, and had done their taxes for years. Their sons lived in Seattle and Dallas. The lawyer’s form asked whether the trustee should give the beneficiaries formal accountings. Harold said, “Denise? She doesn’t need to do all that paperwork for her brothers,” and checked the box waiving them.

June died in 2021, Harold in 2023. Denise became sole trustee of everything: the house in Altadena, a brokerage account, two annuities and a small rental in Monrovia. She meant to do it right. She was also working full time, grieving both parents, and handling a property tax reassessment, a tenant who stopped paying and a roof leak.

Illustration: Trustee, bookkeeper, grieving daughter, landlord, roofer: all of it lands on Denise.
2 · THE TURNING POINTTrustee, bookkeeper, grieving daughter, landlord, roofer: all of it lands on Denise.

Her brothers got the required letter saying the trust had become irrevocable, and then very little. An email in the spring. A text saying “Working on it.” When one of them asked for statements, she sent a single page. After two years of silence, the brothers stopped assuming she was busy and started assuming she was hiding something. They filed a petition asking a judge to make her account.

In the end the books were mostly fine. A few late payments, one loan she had made herself to cover the roof, paid back. But the case cost more than any of it, and the three of them stopped speaking.

Illustration: Working on it wasn’t enough. Two years later, her brothers took it to court.
3 · THE FIGHT“Working on it” wasn’t enough. Two years later, her brothers took it to court.

Which holes lined up

  • One trustee, close by, with brothers far away. Distance turned silence into suspicion.
  • Accountings waived in the trust. California lets a trust waive the regular account in many cases (Probate Code section 16064), and parents often do it to spare a child paperwork. It also removes the one routine report that keeps everyone calm.
  • No regular word. Trustees must keep beneficiaries reasonably informed and answer reasonable requests (Probate Code sections 16060 and 16061), but “reasonably” left room for two years of guessing.
  • Too much for one person. A house, a rental, a brokerage account and annuities are a part-time job.
  • A small loan to herself. Repaid, but a trustee using trust money for her own purposes breaks the duty of loyalty (Probate Code section 16004), and it became the center of the fight.
Illustration: The books were mostly fine. The case cost more. Now nobody calls.
4 · THE AFTERMATHThe books were mostly fine. The case cost more. Now nobody calls.

The one decision that would have changed it

Harold and June’s one decision was the checked box. Waiving the accountings felt kind to Denise. Requiring a short written report every year, to all three children, would have been kinder to all of them.

What would have headed it off

Wording that predicted the trouble

The trust could have required a simple yearly report to every child: what came in, what went out, what’s left, what’s next. Not a court accounting, just a few honest pages. It could also have said plainly that the trustee may never lend trust money to herself. Even with a waiver, the trustee must still send the formal notice within 60 days when the trust becomes irrevocable (Probate Code section 16061.7), and no trust can waive that.

The right size of team

With a rental, a house and several accounts, a co-trustee or a professional fiduciary to help, or permission for Denise to hire a bookkeeper paid by the trust, would have kept the work from swallowing her. A sole trustee is fine for a simple estate; this one wasn’t simple.

Openness by design

A shared online folder where the trustee posts statements every quarter costs nothing and answers most questions before they’re asked. Parents can write that expectation into the trust.

The family told, and on board

Harold and June could have explained their choice to all three children together: why Denise, what she would send them, and how often. Sons in Seattle and Dallas can join on a recorded video call, each stating their name and hearing it from their parents. The signing itself still happens the proper way: a California will needs two witnesses present at the same time (Probate Code section 6110), and trust papers are normally signed in person and notarized. The recorded call is the family hearing it; it never replaces the signing.

Illustration: Harold and June explain why Denise, and how her brothers will see everything.
5 · THE ENDING THAT DIDN’T HAVE TO HAPPENHarold and June explain why Denise, and how her brothers will see everything.

What the plan would have done

With a yearly report written into the trust and a shared folder of statements, Denise’s brothers would have watched the estate settle in real time: the roof, the tenant, the reassessment, the annuities paid out. A bookkeeper paid by the trust would have taken the load off her evenings, and a clear rule against borrowing would have kept the roof money from ever being a question.

The same three siblings, the same assets and the same hard year would have ended with a final distribution and a family dinner, not a petition.

Questions to ask an estate-planning attorney

  1. Should I waive accountings in my trust? What do my children lose if I do?
  2. Can my trust require a yearly written report to every beneficiary?
  3. Is one trustee enough for what I own, or should there be two?
  4. Can the trustee hire a bookkeeper or professional, and be repaid by the trust?
  5. Should my trust say plainly that the trustee can’t borrow from it?
  6. Should my trustee be paid? How much, and who decides?
  7. How should I explain my choice of trustee to my other children?

The page that would have changed this story

Most fights over trustees start with silence, not theft. John’s living trusts page covers how a trust names a trustee and what the trustee owes the family. Back to the Swiss cheese of family estates.

If one of these holes looks familiar, it is far easier to close it now, while everyone can still sit at the same table. Call John at (310) 735-9877, or send a note from the contact page.

Send this to your sister or brother: Email · Text

Families like this one also read:

John J. Donahue, attorney

From the library of John J. Donahue, Attorney · State Bar No. 145817 · Los Angeles since 1990

Naming one child as trustee? John can build in the accountings that keep the others trusting.

What could go wrong · story question

Already in a fight over a will or trust? → myinheritance.com