What could go wrong · A helper who held the keys

The grandson who ran the six-plex

Illustration: Sunday lunch in the courtyard Grandma built her life around.
1 · THE FAMILY WHOLESunday lunch in the courtyard Grandma built her life around.Illustration. Not a real family.

What happened

Helen bought the six-unit building on a side street in Long Beach in 1981, the year after her husband died. For forty years she collected the rents herself, kept the ledger in a green clothbound book, and knew every tenant’s children by name. Her plan, signed in 2009, was simple: the building to her three daughters in equal shares.

When Helen turned eighty-six, the stairs got hard. Her grandson Travis, the eldest daughter’s boy, was between jobs, so Helen made him the building’s manager. He wasn’t much of one. Repairs ran late and the rent book got messy. But he was there, and he was kind to her, and her other grandchildren, Amy and Mark, were glad someone was. They had children and jobs of their own and came on Sundays when they could.

Illustration: He carries her groceries and holds her mail. The tenant’s broken door still waits.
2 · THE TURNING POINTHe carries her groceries and holds her mail. The tenant’s broken door still waits.

Over the next three years Travis came by every morning. He picked up her prescriptions. He had her mail forwarded to the apartment he was using as an office, “so the rent checks don’t sit in the box.” He sat with her when the doctors explained things. When Helen said she wanted to “update her papers,” Travis found a form online, typed what she told him, and drove her to a notary and two neighbors to sign.

The new will left the six-plex to Travis and the rest to her daughters. Helen died at eighty-nine. Two of her daughters found out at the reading, and Amy and Mark found out from them. Nobody thought Travis was a villain. He had earned his grandmother’s trust honestly. But nobody else had been in the room, nobody else had seen her mail for three years, and the building was most of what she owned. It went to court.

Illustration: The grandkids who couldn’t be there every day confront the one who was.
3 · THE FIGHTThe grandkids who couldn’t be there every day confront the one who was.

Which holes lined up

  • One helper with every key. Travis managed the building, the medicine, the mail and the appointments. Nobody else could see in.
  • The mail went with him. Statements, tax bills and letters from the bank stopped reaching anyone but the helper.
  • A will typed by the person it favored. Even with the best intentions, that is the fact a court looks at hardest.
  • The caregiver rule didn’t apply. California presumes undue influence for gifts to many paid caregivers, but not to relatives within the fourth degree, and a grandson is one (Probate Code sections 21380 and 21382). The family had to prove undue influence the old way, which is slower and costlier.
  • No lawyer, no family in the room. The 2009 plan had been made with an attorney. The change was made at a kitchen table.
Illustration: Sundays stopped. Grandma at her window, the table folded against the wall.
4 · THE AFTERMATHSundays stopped. Grandma at her window, the table folded against the wall.

The one decision that would have changed it

Helen’s one decision was in 2009, when she made her plan: she put the building in her own name and a will, with no trust and no instructions for what should happen if she ever needed help running it. A trust with a co-trustee, set up while she was well, would have put a second set of eyes on the building, the bank and the mail. Travis could still have been her manager, and paid for it, without being the only person who knew anything.

What would have headed it off

A trust with a second set of eyes

A living trust holding the six-plex, with Helen as trustee and a daughter named to step in as co-trustee if Helen ever asked for help, would have kept the rents, the bank and the books visible to more than one person. A written management agreement could have paid Travis a fair monthly fee for the building work, in plain terms, so everyone knew what he earned and why.

Wishes said out loud

If Helen wanted Travis to have more than the others, she could have said so in writing and explained why: the years of work, the mornings, the care. A short letter in her own words, kept with her plan, turns a surprise into a decision the family heard from her.

The attorney in the room, not the helper

When Helen wanted to change her plan, the change should have gone through her lawyer, who meets with her alone. The helper drives her to the office and waits in the lobby. The lawyer asks Helen what she owns, who her family is, and what she wants. That meeting is the best evidence later that the change was hers.

The family told, and on board

If Helen had chosen to leave the building to Travis, all three daughters could have heard it from her directly, in one family meeting. A daughter who lives out of state can join on a recorded video call, with each person stating their name and Helen explaining her reasons. The signing itself still happens the proper way: a California will needs two witnesses present at the same time (Probate Code section 6110), and trust papers are normally signed in person and notarized. The recorded call is the family hearing it; it never replaces the signing.

Illustration: Grandma tells every grandchild herself, on camera, while she is strong.
5 · THE ENDING THAT DIDN’T HAVE TO HAPPENGrandma tells every grandchild herself, on camera, while she is strong.

What the plan would have done

With a trust and a co-trustee in place, Helen’s rents, bank statements and tax bills would have gone to two people, not one. Travis would still have come every morning and been paid fairly for running the building, under a written agreement everyone could read. If Helen had wanted to leave him more, she would have said so to her lawyer alone and to her daughters together, and her reasons would be on paper and on a recording.

Her daughters might not all have liked it. But they would have heard it from Helen, and there would have been nothing left to guess about. The building, the ledger and the family would have come through intact.

Questions to ask an estate-planning attorney

  1. If someone in the family starts helping me every day, how does my plan protect both of us?
  2. Should my rental property be in a trust, and who would step in if I need help running it?
  3. Can a family member be paid for managing my property or caring for me? How do we put that in writing?
  4. Who should get copies of my statements and tax bills if I am not opening my own mail?
  5. If I want to leave more to the person who helps me, how do I do that so it holds up?
  6. Will you meet with me alone when I make changes?
  7. How should I tell the rest of my family about the change?

The page that would have changed this story

A rental building owned in your own name is the kind of asset that needs a plan for the day you need help. John’s living trusts page explains how a trust with a co-trustee works, and the durable power of attorney page covers who can act for you, and how that can be watched. Back to the Swiss cheese of family estates.

If one of these holes looks familiar, it is far easier to close it now, while everyone can still sit at the same table. Call John at (310) 735-9877, or send a note from the contact page.

Send this to your sister or brother: Email · Text

Families like this one also read:

John J. Donahue, attorney

From the library of John J. Donahue, Attorney · State Bar No. 145817 · Los Angeles since 1990

One child or grandchild running a parent’s building, mail and medicine? John can help set up a plan that pays them fairly and keeps everyone informed.

What could go wrong · story question